For an extra layer of flavor, consider using a high-quality vanilla bean ice cream. Adjust the amount of butter flavoring to suit your taste. Start with less and add more as needed. Ensure all ingredients are well-chilled before mixing for the best results. To avoid excessive fizz, pour the cream soda slowly and gently.
Jacinthe Spinka
May 12, 2025This recipe was a hit at our Harry Potter party! Everyone loved the balanced flavor and said it tasted just like they imagined Butterbeer would.
Lessie Ernser
May 2, 2025I was hesitant about the butter flavoring, but it really made the drink! I used a tiny bit more than the recipe called for and it was perfect.
Ettie Kuhlman
Apr 24, 2025So much better than other butterbeer recipes I've tried! Not too sweet and the rum gives it a nice kick.